Three Sparks: A True Story

"Absent in body, but present in spirit."
St. Paul, Corinthians 5:3

PAULEY = JOLLY + FOLLY
Three years after Paul died, John Salisbury emailed Tammy: “I thought you would like to know that there is at least one Paul reference every shift, and as you may have guessed many are funny and X-rated. In all my time here, and out of all of the people that have ‘left’ this place, Pauley is the only person that left that big of an impression. No one else even comes close. We still miss him.” John told me Paul’s legacy is tough to put into words, but for him part of it was the realization that you don’t necessarily know what you’ve got till it’s gone. For PFA, it was a newfound awareness of the importance of character. “Paul made them look really hard at how we promote people,” John observed. “Hey, this guy should’ve been an officer all along. Truth is he was one of the best of us.” And over-the-top fun to boot. “He knew no moderation,” John reminisced. “He loved to watch videos about hunting. He really loved to hunt varmints. We’d practice on prairie dogs during our redneck days at Pawnee Grasslands. There’d be five or six of us and 30-40 guns on the table: two guns for each of us, 10 guns for Pauley. He was an amazing shot.” He was also pretty good at cooking his firehouse favorite sloppy joes and tater tots. Brian Raisley is grateful to this day for the chapter in his life that included Paul Gaucher. “I’m fortunate to have shared it with somebody like Paul,” Brian said. “It’s taken me a long time to come to a good place with it. We shared some of the most horrific calls and some of the best, too. I have no bad memories. It was awesome. I’m more appreciative and truthful in the day-to-day for those friendships.” Brian called Paul a smart guy, a brilliant dad, and 100-percent fun. “He was up for anything,” Brian said, grinning with the knowingness of a repeat conspirator. “That’s why I liked hanging out with him. We did stuff I normally wouldn’t be doing.” So many more stories, so few more pages, and Bryan Hanson wanted to make sure he’s properly conveyed to me and you, Dear Reader, just who and how Paul Gaucher was: he was a man who loved his work and his freedom from work equally. “Those that want to put firefighters up on a pedestal…don’t,” Bryan warned. “We’re the same guys that come to your house to light your water heaters. You get sick at the store, we’re there.” Firefighting, family, and fun were the fuels that kept Paul going. His dedication to whichever of the three he was currently engaged in or with, filled him with energy and strength. He could, quite literally, get so fired up. He loved what he loved and who he loved with a passion. “Pauley was really into guns,” Bryan said, recapping John’s account of rodent kill quests in detail too graphic for even this horror fan. “We were also on a coed softball team together, along with our wives, which was just a blast. And then there was golfing, which Paul also loved. He’d line up his shot and shout, ‘Heads up!’” Bryan hijacked an annual golf event held to raise money for PFA’s annual holiday celebration at New Belgium Brewery, and morphed it into The Paul Gaucher Memorial “1 Club” Golf Tourney, played with balls thusly imprinted. Free shot do-overs, aka mulligans on every other course, became “pauligans,” purchased with fake currency festooned with Paul’s face. Teams were picked by draw, out of a hat, and players were allowed only one BYOC (yep, Bring Your Own Club) for the entire course. Among the prizes awarded was a traveling trophy for the team with the highest score. Proceeds from the Sept. 18, 2012 outing benefitted the Hands up Cooperative in its work to supply jobs for the homeless in Fort Collins. The flyer promoting said event featured front and center a monkey putting. “Paul would be proud,” Bryan said immodestly. “Tammy and Whit played (that first year). We’re family forever.”
PUTTING FIRES OUT
On Oct. 14, 2020, after raging for 62-days during a global pandemic, the Cameron Peak Fire became the largest wildfire in Colorado history at 164,140-acres. It would grow to 208,913-acres before 100-percent containment was reached on Dec. 2. Remarkably no one died in the fire, which destroyed a total of 469 structures, 224 of which were residences. The Coloradoan reported that Ray and Mary Caraway were among those who lost homes when theirs in Redwood Canyon burned to the ground in mid-October. The Caraways were the family I wrote about in 2012 whose home in Bonner Peak Ranch was threatened by the High Park Fire. “It was like the fire drills in school,” Ray was quoted as saying. “You do what you have to do, but you never think it’s actually going to happen.” As masked folks maintained their distance, transfixed by a blood red sun while ash fluttered down upon them, whispers of Revelations, Armageddon, and the End Times somehow at the time didn’t seem all that farfetched. What does seem fanciful is that we’re already more than two decades into the “new” millennium, which means a generation of Americans wasn’t born when 9/11 happened. The Coloradoan marked the deadly disaster’s 20th anniversary with a front page story I would’ve read word-for-word even if Bryan Hanson’s face and name hadn’t jumped out at me. Fragments of the opening of this chapter may seem familiar as some of it appears in the book. While what follows deviates from the story arc, it’s important to another story: that of 9/11 and Poudre Fire Authority’s connection to that fateful day. The rest of the chapter provides insight into PFA’s continuing commitment to the community and to its own. Reporter Sady Swanson interviewed another PFA first responder, Rick Vander Velde, about his deployment to Ground Zero as part of Colorado Task Force 1 Urban Search and Rescue. Rick was with the Longmont Fire Department on 9/11 and shared with readers his experience along with a photo of Bryan and the PFA group of seven, who were among the 62 Coloradans on a transformational rescue and recovery mission to NYC. The newspaper headline somberly reminded us that we’d collectively pledged to “Never Forget.” The United We Stand signs, banners, and bumper sticks that were everywhere then may seem like a faraway fantasy now, but the connectedness we felt was real. As a permanent reminder of 9/11 and our shared trauma, there now exits a memorial at Fort Collin’s Spring Creek Park, next to PFA Station 3, where a steel I-beam pulled from the WTC wreckage is mounted above three pools of cascading water. The beam is surrounded by 343 pavers, one for each of the 343 firefighters killed in the 2001 terrorist attack. We The People vowed to never forget. At the unveiling on July 1, 2024, PFA and City of Fort Collins leaders said they hoped the memorial will be a place where the community can reflect and remember, as well as a monument for new generations so they, too, can honor the sacrifices of first responders. I loved this gem I found on the city’s website during the fundraising process: “By telling their story, we acknowledge that the response to tragedy defines a community more than the tragedy itself.” There was an earlier front paper newspaper piece in which Bryan Hanson had caught my eye, pictured standing at attention beside the afore-mentioned beam. Sady wrote this Sept. 11, 2019 story, too, and quoted PFA Fire Inspector Hanson as saying that it was “surreal and humbling” to be among those chosen in 2015 to bring the beam home to FoCo from NYC. A month later, Bryan walked with Coloradoan reporter Erin Udell in Grandview Cemetery among the headstones surrounding a 1909 statue of a firefighter. Bryan pointed out the side-by-side graves of Paul Gaucher and Rick Gonzales, and, a stone’s throw away, that of Jerry Hanson, Byran’s brother. All three firefighters died in separate off-duty accidents. With space dwindling in Grandview, Poudre Fire Authority and the City of Fort Collins publically reserved the five remaining plots for firefighters killed in the line of duty. An ossuary, capable of housing the cremains of more than 100 PFA firefighters and their immediate family members, along with civilian support staffers, was also dedicated. Tammy emailed me after the Oct. 4, 2019 ceremony: “It’s nice that Paul is remembered in the article. Paul loved working for PFA. It was more than just a job. It was his calling. It meant a lot to Paul to have Nick buried in the firefighter section, and he knew that one day, he would join his son in this space.” Several days a week, Paul’s daughter is joined in a space frequented by PFA firefighters, law enforcement officers, ex-military special ops, and other elite professional athletes. CrossFit has been part of Whitney Whitehead’s world since before her dad died. CrossFit describes itself as “a training philosophy that coaches people of all shapes and sizes to improve their physical well-being and cardiovascular fitness in a hardcore yet accepting and encouraging environment…Our specialty is not specializing…the goal…building a body that’s capable of practically anything and everything.” A couple of weeks after Paul’s accident, CrossFit Ken Caryl in Littleton hosted a Paul Gaucher Memorial WOD and Training Night. (WOD is Workout of the Day during which firefighters were encouraged to participate in full gear.) Bryan Hanson sent me a link to the Facebook page promoting the Aug. 29, 2012 event, which suggested a $20 donation the Gaucher Family wanted to redirect to The Children’s Hospital Foundation. “Thank you in advance for supporting Colorado’s Firefighters when they need you,” the closing lines read. “Rest in Honored Peace, Pauly. This one is for you, Brother.” Paul’s fellow firefighters and CrossFit owners Gene “Gino” Macarini and Jon McKeon gifted Whitney with a lifetime membership, which has paid off in unexpected ways by connecting Whitney with several of her dad’s contacts. “I need to meet Whitney,” a wife of one of the firefighters said in approaching her one day. “I need to let you know,” Yasi Tarin further explained, “your dad had the biggest impact on my husband, on PFA, on how to treat others.” Her spouse Jorge Tarin would be the one to draw up the architectural plans for the Whiteheads’ house. Olivia “Liv” Deadmond was new to firefighting when she and Whitney crossed paths on the road to fitness. “The guys are still telling stories!” Liv exclaimed to Whitney, who told me that she and Liv have become really good friends, and that “Liv tells me she hears Paul stories to this day.” Among Liv’s workout music selections is a set she calls Paul’s Playlist.
STRAIGHT TALK FROM PAUL'S GIRLS
“Paul was the good parent.” There aren’t many moms among us who would reveal that kind of insight into their family dynamics, but then Tammy Gaucher always has been honest to a fault and quite hard on herself. “I was too stressed out,” Tammy said. “The babies would be crying, crying, in the middle of the night, and so would I. Paul would come to the rescue, take the baby from my arms and immediately console them.” Was Paul a perfect parent? Is there such a thing? Tammy drudged up a memory from Base Camp to illustrate a scenario of another kind, this one starring a not-as-cool-dad. Nick was in kindergarten and Whitney was a second-grader. It was Paul’s turn to pick up the kids after school, and, boy oh boy, was he upset at what he saw when he got there. Whitney and a friend had Nick and his friend Zach all dolled up in girlie girl stuff. It was all this man’s man could do not to dress everyone down on the spot. This same he-man would get teary each and every time he watched Sling Blade. You’ll have to watch the 1996 film written and directed by its star Billy Bob Thornton to see why a grown man would cry. Oh, how Nick idolized his dad! He wanted to do whatever his dad did. “Paul was Nick’s dad, his hero, his best friend,” Tammy said. Nick’s other best friend was his sister. Whitney agreed both were true. There was no getting in between “the boys” when they were on a roll—except for the times when she was one of the boys. “We’re at the grocery store, and Dad chucks this kumquat across the produce section to me, and just walks off,” Whitney said, still shaking her head at the audacity of it all. Tammy’s grateful for her daughter’s sure hands, but still wonders why her husband had to pick the priciest piece of fruit. To illustrate how these boys will be those boys, Whit shared this: “We’d go out to dinner, and they are shooting spit wads (made of straw wrappers) at each other like two children.” Oh, boy. The Gaucher offspring did have something of a sibling relationship going on with their pop, which made the times when Paul wanted to be an imposing father figure challenging. “You can’t do both,” Tammy said with the sage of someone speaking from experience. “As Dad, Paul wanted to be the kids’ best friend, not the disciplinarian. He wanted to be liked.” One guess as to who did the heavy lifting when it came to discipline. But when it came to sports, it was Team Gaucher all the way. “Dad was very involved. He loved going to games and practices,” Whitney said. “He would brag to people about me, years after I played softball.” Paul really did dig softball. “He was a better player in his own mind,” Tammy kidded. Then she added another dig of a different kind. “He also liked to try to play volleyball.” If Paul’s firstborn and only daughter were to describe her very active papa in one word, it would be “social.” His wife didn’t hesitate to agree. “He loved people and being around them,” Tammy said. “At retail stores, he was always explaining something to clerks they had no business knowing.” “TMI, Dad!” Whitney interjected. Suffice it to say, there were some awkward silences on the other side of the counter when the Gauchers were in the checkout lane at Walmart. Contrariwise, Whitney and her mom would often get one-word answers when on the phone with Paul, but when one of the guys called, Whit said, “It was like two little high school girls.” Whitney believes her dad was involved in every single PFA party there ever was. “He just had to be there, wherever there was free beer and people,” she said. “Dad was the first to arrive and last to leave. He was the life of the party.” Official department ceremonies were another “essential duty” Paul took seriously. “He’d go to meet the new guys,” Tammy said. “Paul knew all the guys.” And all the guys knew Paul. A firefighter from Station No. 5 texted Tammy not so long ago that it just isn’t the same without Paul. Paul was known for his sense of humor, for being fun, and for joking around, but it was his overall positive attitude that left a vacuum few can fill. “The guys are missing that spark,” Tammy said without having to say, “Me, too.” “He was one of those people: ‘Pauley’s here!’ And the room lights up,” Whitney said, wistfully, like her mom, not-so-secretly wishing he still was here. “He could always find a way to make the guys laugh,” Tammy said. Whit nodded, “Yeah, he’d wait till he got home to vent.” Paul’s wife and daughter are forever proud their man’s memory is treated with respect by his peers to this day, because it’s true, as Whitney put it with Paul-esque frankness, he just didn’t tolerate any crap. That familial pride went both ways. Tammy said Paul once asked her why she and the kids didn’t stop by the firehouse more often. “Other families would come visit, and I think that was his way of saying he was proud of us,” Tammy smiled at the thought of Paul wanting of show off his cool brood. Paul was a good husband with a capacity for listening that made him an even better partner. Tammy often called Paul at work, naturally, since Paul was often at work. “I’d want to talk. He would listen. He tried to be strong for us,” said Tammy, momentarily lost in the thought of just how much she’s lost and how it feels to be truly lost. “He kept it together for us.” It wasn’t until after he passed that Tammy wondered where Paul got help. “When you’re both in it, it’s hard to be there for each other,” she acknowledged. Tammy realized, but only after Bryan, John, Brian, and others told her so, that Paul would talk a lot to his colleagues. “Paul was like a lot of men,” Tammy said. “He didn’t want to show his emotions but if someone needed him, he would be there for them. He had a deep, sensitive side that he would open up if someone was receptive to it.” On the other hand, Paul was constantly lending a hand, whether it was cleaning Clara’s gutters, or helping a fellow firefighter with whatever needing fixing. “He hardly ever asked for help,” Whitney said. “He NEVER asked for help,” Tammy clarified. “He didn’t want to impose on others.” Paul was a good worker, and Whitney wanted to make sure we got how good. “He took his time,” she said. “He had one speed: slow. He’d be standing there in the garage, shirt off, looking side-to-side.” Paul Gaucher was heavy duty; he was physically strong, emotionally resilient, and mentally tough. “Everything we went through with Nick…” Tammy stopped and shook her head, indicating how losing her only son to cancer remains to this day impossible to fully comprehend. “If Paul hadn’t been as strong…well, I don’t know how I would’ve been.” As outgoing, social, and positive as Paul was, he could turn into a bear. “The Protector” is what Tammy called him for Paul was all claws when it came to anything threatening her and the kids. Tammy marvels when others tell her how strong she is, because she doesn’t see herself that way. “It’s the people around me that give me strength,” she said.
THE VISION DIVISION OF THE DREAM TEAM
The subconscious is something of a storage locker for what is just out of reach of your conscious mind. Dreams can tap into what’s hidden there, bring information to the surface, and maybe help make sense of it all. We can theorize all day into the night about the dream state, but, like signs, an absolute science, this is not. Not yet, anyway. Nick told Morgan, “I’ll see if heaven’s for real…I’ll give you a sign.” Zero, zip, zilch, till out of the email ethers in 2011, Nick’s cousin on Tammy’s Spencer side of the family, Ashlie Perry, wrote Morgan about a dream she’d had about Nick. Ashlie said she was a little worried that Morgan would think she was weird, but at the same time she couldn’t not write, so write she did: “I had a very vivid dream about Nick the other night and he brought you up specifically. He told me that he wanted you to know that he watches over you and tries to help guide you the right way when he can, and that he’s very happy for you and the family you’ve created. I don’t know if you believe in God, but I believe you have a very special angel watching over you…You were very special to him. I remember the first time I asked him about you and he turned SO red. It was too cute. I wasn’t gonna say anything ‘cause I figured it might weird you out, but he is obviously trying to reach out to you.” Ashlie told me she dreams of Nick pretty frequently. “He’s as I last remember him,” she said. “The same age, but healthy, with hair, and he looks good. He’s dressed nice, more formal, no raunchy tees!” Morgan doesn’t know what to think and blames herself for not listening. “It’s hard to put into words how much Nick means to me,” she said. Laurel’s dreamed of Nick, too: “It’s dark. He’s walking down the hall. There are guys in the hallway. I can’t remember who all’s there. Nick passes us. He’s walking the other way. That’s it.” Joe used to dream about Nick a lot when he was a kid, and once in a while, he still does. “We were just kids again, hanging out like we used to,” he said, smirking like only a mischievous teen can. “Old memories, mostly; he’s happy, healthy, not at all sick.” For two weeks straight, Joe said he dreamed nightly of Nick, watching their carefree childhoods replayed for him in Dreamland like old home movies. Then he’d awake, sad to find himself in the present and alone. “Quit doing this to me, man,” Joe beseeched, bereft of his still-absent buddy. “I miss the sh*t out of you!” With a failed wine bar under his belt, Joe went back to school and to the technology he and Nick ruled back in the day. “He was a normal kid,” Joe pondered. “So why am I, why are we, still talking about him? Because he was way older (not in years but in maturity) than any of us. How lucky was I?” As terrible as the experience was, the adult Joe said it was also really cool even if it did make Joe grow up “pretty quick.” “You don’t know what anyone else is going through,” Joe observed. “I finally realized I can’t help but be compassionate. Knowing Nick made me the person I am.” As for an adult Nick? Joe believes it’s a tossup between Nick as a firefighter or in baseball. “As much as he loved football and the Packers, he loved, loved the Yankees,” Joe said with a grin and a faraway gaze. Rose Gaucher told Tammy about a family who connected with her due to the donation jar she had on the counter of the floral department she managed at a Kroger store in Seattle. Rose had posted a photo of her nephew Nick along with his story. The five-year-old son of one of her customer’s had died of bone cancer in his leg. The child told his mom that he’d seen the kid in the grocery store flying above his bed at home with one chicken wing, which was his way of saying “angel wing.” Later, the mom came in and said she dreamed about Nick and her son. They were running, her boy with healthy legs and Nick with both arms. The year Nick died Rose took part in the Avon Breast Cancer 3-Day Walk event in Seattle. A woman walked up to her, put her arm around Rose and said, “I just need to let you know I can see this young man walking next to you. He’s got the biggest, brightest smile.” Rose burst into tears. By the time Rose regained her composure, the woman was nowhere to be found. In Tammy’s dreams, Nick’s always young, sometimes with cancer, sometimes without, and always just out of reach. She shares one: she’s at the airport, waiting. In bounds a bunch of kids from Nick’s baseball team. Nick’s there, too, happy, healthy. Tammy remembers wondering, why am I not at the tourney? “Sometimes he’s sick, I can’t touch him, but not this dream,” she says. “He’s got this big smile on his face.” Then Tammy wakes up. She can’t help feeling sad, remembering the reality is Nick is not there. The December after Nick died, Tammy was vacuuming. She was dumbfounded to discover that the machine had picked up a diamond earring she’d lost months ago. “There’s no way it was laying there all that time,” Tammy exclaimed. “I looked high and low for it.” She isn’t sure if this was Nick’s doing, but she is sure it was something other than dumb luck.
DREAMING UP THE NEXT CHAPTER
After the funeral, Tammy spent a week in Newport Beach, CA. She dreamed she was there with Paul. “It was very vivid,” she said. “We were making love. It was comforting. It felt like he was literally telling me goodbye and that he loved me.” Most of her Paul dreams since have been classic abandonment dreams in which her husband disappears, entirely understandable from a widow’s window looking out onto Dreamland. While Whitney experiences no dreamy images of her dad, she does report often reliving memories, both in a dream state and while awake, of him when he was alive. “It’s like he’s really there; not gone,” she said. Whitney did relay the dream a spinning class friend had: Liz Jackson, wife of A.J., another of Paul’s firefighter brothers, dreamed Paul called her on the phone. “I’m okay,” he said. In the history of one-sided, two-worded conversations, he couldn’t have picked a more impactful pair to share. Brian Raisley has also been blessed to dream about his pal Paul. Brian recalls nothing much about these dreams upon awakening, only Paul’s reactions. “It’s his laugh,” Brian said. “Every moment is followed by a laugh.” Tammy has dreamed of her husband before and since. Other times, maybe it’s the Universe messing around with her. Shortly after Paul’s death, Tammy was watching the 1961 movie based on Tennessee Williams’ short novel The Roman Spring of Mrs. Stone. Vivien Leigh plays the title role, a recently widowed 50-something who becomes infatuated with an attractive young Paolo di Leo (Warren Beatty), who has his own agenda which isn’t good for her. About two-thirds of the way through the film, the TV screen went gray, a first, and so far one-time occurrence. “I believe that was Paul telling me, ‘Stop it. This isn’t you’,” Tammy said. In death, disembodied himself, was Paul trying to lift Tammy’s spirits as he so often did in life? Paul shared with his wife that he’d dreamed about the World Trade Center. “The next thing I knew,” Tammy said, “a plane flew into the north tower.” Did Paul Gaucher have a premonition? There are many published accounts from others, including victims, who believe they “saw something” 9/11-related before the September 11, 2001 atrocity. The summer of 2013 for me flew like they all do. This book project was in its infancy, but already influencing my dream state. On Aug. 17, I dreamed of the Gauchers: I was at their house, interviewing Whitney and Tammy, but there is now just so much more house! The kitchen, which Paul and Tammy had recently remodeled together for reals, was its same gorgeously updated self, but now there is an entire section that used to be an upscale mall with restaurant and retail space, spectacular hardwood floors, and knockout décor. It’s HUGE and faces Main Street (which in reality is four blocks south). For the record, there is no second floor, but there is now an upstairs art gallery featuring wall-sized portraits of Nick and Paul. Friends and family are everywhere, mulling about in a space that is so open and just beautiful. “Is this their heavenly forever home?” I asked no one in particular. “Cousin” is hounding me to interview him. Nick is his role model and he wants everyone to know that fact. Everyone is going out for yet another drink. “I’ve got to drive, y’know,” I demur but an older dude insists. “Let me just get my shoes,” I agree. I woke up with Bluff, our polydactyl black cat, wrapped around my head like a scarf. Do dogs dream? Anyone who’s let sleeping dogs lie would say, yes, a thousand times, yes. Psychology Today agrees, just not quite as unequivocally enthusiastically. The magazine posted a piece that suggests a dog’s sleep-induced quivering, leg twitching, growling, etc. seems to be directed at someone or in response to something seen in the dream state. The PsychologyToday.com article explains how at the structural level, the brains of dogs are similar to those of humans, right down to the brainwave patterns during sleepy-bye-time. Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) researchers posit that it would be way more surprising to discover dogs don’t dream. Matthew Wilson and Kenway Louie found evidence that the brains of simpler and less intelligent animals, i.e., rats, are functioning in a way that sure seems similar to dreamtime, which is also likely associated with their daytime activities. Shudder. Rats are definitely on my list of Top 10 Terrorizing Things That Make Me Wake Up in a Cold Sweat. Wonder if lab rats find humans, especially those clad in white coats with deep pockets, equally nightmarish? Jeter The Pug certainly wasn’t dreaming, but he had conjured up something in Nick’s bedroom his humans weren’t seeing. Jeter just kept staring and staring at nothing. Tammy and Whitney were never able to account for their dog’s odd behavior that day, but noted that this was right around the first anniversary of Paul’s death and that Paul’s flag and helmet were in Nick’s room. Homer was Nick’s dog, a sensitive canine tethered to his boy but in a leash-less way. After Nick died, Homer peed on Nick’s bed, something he’d never done before and never did again. Anyone who’s spent any time around animals knows animals are in tune with their intuition and use it all the time. (Would that humans would follow their lead here!) When Paul’s crumpled up bike ended up in the Whiteheads’ garage, Debbie reported their dogs started acting really weird, even for really weird dogs. The cats, too, behaved as if there was something else there, something their humans were missing. The bike has long since been repaired and sold.

